Previous Page/Table Of ContentsNext Page



G . Is "Progress" Real?

The title of this Section represents probably the central question which Will Durant set out to answer with his Story of Civilization. He first posed it as Chapter XV of his Mansions of Philosophy (1929),100 and then concluded the thought with the concluding chapter of The Lessons of History (1968). In both cases, he took the affirmative position, asserting in essence that the view of "progress" as an illusion was, in essence, a two dimensional view of a three dimensional phenomena. As individual civilizations each make the trek outlined by Spengler, from savagery through civilization and back again, each adds something to overall human knowledge, and to that extent, contributes to human "progress." Thus, the path for civilization is not a two dimensional circle of the successive rises and falls of individual societies, but instead the three dimensional spiral of "progress" upward, with each civilization arising, to one degree or another, on the backs of those which have preceded it.
There is no essential doubt that this "progress" is "real." The true issue which most people would raise with this same question is whether or not "progress" is desirable. Is mankind better off with "progress" than without it? If you cannot answer that question in the affirmative, then any measurable achievements of "progress" are, in fact, delusions, since they would have contributed adversely (or at least, nothing) to the overall health of mankind.
xxx.


100 The actual title of Chapter XV was "Is Progress A Delusion?"

Copyright 1994-1999 by the Agnostic Church

Please send us your feedback!

Previous Page/Table Of ContentsNext Page