Previous Page/Table Of ContentsNext Page



E . Cosmology And The Other Sciences

Once a field of thought is turned over to the careful ministrations of scientific method, it becomes for all time removed from control by mythology or religion.56 One of the most significant advances by Western Civilization was the submission of cosmology to the dominion of science. If a dividing line must be drawn, the first person of "modern history" is probably Galileo,57 of whom the Encyclopaedia Brittanica says:

What Galileo introduced was a profound philosophical change for mankind. For all of prior history, if mankind studied the stars, he did so in order to gain an insight into the gods which ruled his existence. Astrology was a much respected science in virtually all civilizations, including Western Civilization before Galileo. Galileo divorced the gods from the Cosmos, and subjected the Cosmos to the scientific method. After four centuries of carefully controlled inquiry, mankind has a grasp of what really exists in our universe which ancient man could never have achieved.58 So, unlike the Classical Greco-Roman civilization, and even early Western Civilization, each of which viewed cosmology as a branch of religion, modern man views cosmology as a branch of Astronomy.
But this does not really divorce cosmology from Philosophy. Remember that a true Philosophy must embrace all of scientific knowledge, not excluding anything. Thus, modern man might well embrace the words of Carl Sagan in the beginnings of his book and television series "Cosmos," where he said:

The Cosmos book and television series presents an overview of how Western Civilization views the place of mankind within the "overall scheme of things," and how we eventually arrived at that viewpoint after many centuries of thought. I highly recommend either to anyone who wishes to grasp many of the essential concepts of Western Civilization and their historical underpinnings.
But the essential Philosophical point is this: any philosophy which is based upon reason (as opposed to faith) will naturally discover all that we will ever know about the Cosmos and the natural laws which rule our existence. Any philosophy which is based upon some other principle, such as faith, will eventually be forced to deny some portion of reality in order to continue to flourish. We see these forces at work in our own times. The essence of the ongoing debate over the teaching of creationism or evolution in our schools is an attempt by the Christian "Right" to deny the reality of evolution because it does not fit with the world view of fundamentalist Christianity. It should be the goal of every "right thinking" individual in our society to stand against the reactionary forces of the Christian "Right," who attempt to brainwash our children, thereby stealing from all mankind the intellectual capacity of those children to think in a scientific manner.


56 Religion and mythology are really synonymous. One man's God is another man's myth.

57 Galileo Galilei was born on February 15, 1564 and died of fever on January 8, 1642.

58 For basically two reasons: no telescopes and a tendency to blame everything, good or bad, on various supernatural forces.

59 It is exactly the true scale of this "immensity and eternity" which led those who preceded us on this planet to shroud its origins in mythology. Before the invention of Arab numerals, mankind lacked the ability to easily express numbers of sufficient size, let alone the mathematics required to manipulate those numbers and the scientific instruments necessary to create the raw measurements themselves.

60 This sentence is an expression of Carl Sagan's essential pacifism, a world view which did not endear him to any in the so-called "Right," let alone the Christian "Right."

61 The majority of this excerpt is transcribed from the television series. However, the part within square brackets is taken from the accompanying book of the same name, Cosmos (1980).

62 This speech was introducing the first of several fanciful space flights which illustrated his points about the immensity of the Cosmos and the innocuous position of mankind in the Cosmos.

63 Again, Cosmology was one of the traditional branches of Philosophy, and a Philosophy is one of the essential ingredients of a Culture.

64 This is the essential mission of science, but it is the "great enemy" of mythology and religion. Superstition cannot stand the bright white light of "Truth," and both mythology and traditional religion depend upon superstition for survival. This is what led to such things as the religious persecution of Galileo.

65 Again, these are the essential ingredients to "scientific method."

66 Again, the part within square brackets is from the book.

67 This refers to his subsequent presentation of his view of the Cosmos.

68 This is an overly cute expression of viewpoint, sort of like: men and women are the method by which sperm and ovum reproduce themselves.

69 Again, the part within square brackets is from the book. This thought expresses the basic enmity between science and any system of thought based upon "faith," which includes all of mythology and religion.

70 The part within square brackets is a visual note. Since the text was taken from the television series, it denotes the meaning of the word "here" in the text.

71 At this point in the television series, he began the first of the imaginary space flights.

72 The footnote in the text explains that the words "billion" and "trillion" will be used as they are in American scientific literature: one billion is 109 (1,000,000,000), while one trillion is 1012 (1,000,000,000,000).

73 For example, take the DNA odds at the O. J. Simpson trial, where numbers in the billions were used to "prove" that certain blood stains came from certain specific people. The prosecution called those numbers "compelling evidence."

Copyright 1994-1999 by the Agnostic Church

Please send us your feedback!

Previous Page/Table Of ContentsNext Page